Out of nowhere, Lisandro Martinez called out Jason Wilcox and the suits calling the shots and Manchester United. It’s about time they came to face the music.
I agree that sporting directors should be more accountable, but I wonder whether we're confusing accountability with visibility and I say that as someone who in the past wanted to see Richard Hughes answer questions about recruitment.
Having them face the cameras after a defeat might be satisfying as a supporter but, objectively, does little in improving how the club is run.
I'm going to agree with Paul. The issue isn't just a lack of accountability. It's that at United, and as a Liverpool fan it's been fun to watch, there's a real feeling of a front office in disarray, rudderless, just sort of going through the motions. As a fan in general, I think the PL needs a Man U that is competative and well organized. What saved Liverpool in those post Gillette and Hicks early years was that FSG implemented a structure. Even though it took a few years, it got going and we've really seen the club hold their position in this era of big changes.
But while I don't think the front office blokes should be answering questions after matches, they should be involved in pressers during the week. Hard to see how that builds any accountability when they're not facing a scrum of journos.
Totally agree. I think United are the prime example of the fundamental contradiction in the modern sporting director model. Sporting directors increasingly demand greater control over recruitment and long-term strategy, hence the shift from managers to head coaches. Yet they rarely face the same public scrutiny as the coaches operating within the structures they create. They want the power to shape the club’s direction without having to publicly explain or defend their decisions.
In Germany, it’s remarkably normal to have the sporting director or figurehead behind squad planning on the bench during matches. They’re also very active in the media with interviews to TV and in press conferences.
Hell, after losing our final game of the season in Osnabrück back in 2024, Hertha stuck with another season in the 2nd division. Benny Weber, our sporting director, came over to the fans with the players. Managed to get a high five from him + the players as they to the fence.
In comparison to the Premier League, completely agree with your assessment.
I actually think media pressure on directors would do Utd good. Isn’t that the same pressure that keeps managers and players honest? (In theory anyway)
Not necessarily married to that method of keeping them in check, but something clearly needs to change. Current system coddles them way too much.
I agree that sporting directors should be more accountable, but I wonder whether we're confusing accountability with visibility and I say that as someone who in the past wanted to see Richard Hughes answer questions about recruitment.
Having them face the cameras after a defeat might be satisfying as a supporter but, objectively, does little in improving how the club is run.
I'm going to agree with Paul. The issue isn't just a lack of accountability. It's that at United, and as a Liverpool fan it's been fun to watch, there's a real feeling of a front office in disarray, rudderless, just sort of going through the motions. As a fan in general, I think the PL needs a Man U that is competative and well organized. What saved Liverpool in those post Gillette and Hicks early years was that FSG implemented a structure. Even though it took a few years, it got going and we've really seen the club hold their position in this era of big changes.
But while I don't think the front office blokes should be answering questions after matches, they should be involved in pressers during the week. Hard to see how that builds any accountability when they're not facing a scrum of journos.
Totally agree. I think United are the prime example of the fundamental contradiction in the modern sporting director model. Sporting directors increasingly demand greater control over recruitment and long-term strategy, hence the shift from managers to head coaches. Yet they rarely face the same public scrutiny as the coaches operating within the structures they create. They want the power to shape the club’s direction without having to publicly explain or defend their decisions.
In Germany, it’s remarkably normal to have the sporting director or figurehead behind squad planning on the bench during matches. They’re also very active in the media with interviews to TV and in press conferences.
Hell, after losing our final game of the season in Osnabrück back in 2024, Hertha stuck with another season in the 2nd division. Benny Weber, our sporting director, came over to the fans with the players. Managed to get a high five from him + the players as they to the fence.
In comparison to the Premier League, completely agree with your assessment.
I actually think media pressure on directors would do Utd good. Isn’t that the same pressure that keeps managers and players honest? (In theory anyway)
Not necessarily married to that method of keeping them in check, but something clearly needs to change. Current system coddles them way too much.